Here's the ultimate gaming controllers for comfort: an expert’s guide

Through the years, online game controllers have modified past all recognition. What commenced as a joystick and a single button with the Atari 2600 has modified to feature more buttons, joysticks, shoulder buttons or even triggers. 

Controllers these days are complex beasts certainly. They’ve nonetheless got the D-pads and face buttons which have continued since the days of the SNES, but similarly contemporary controllers have  thumb-sticks, two shoulder buttons, and two triggers as properly. as if that wasn’t sufficient already, some additionally vibrate and motion-track for proper measure.

As gamers, we’ve gotten used to how controllers paintings. We’ve gotten used to a way to keep them, and what prolonged use of them does to our palms and posture, but we wanted to understand how well they’re designed from an ergonomics perspective. 

Neil Mansfield is a professor of layout Engineering and Human factors within the Dyson college of layout Engineering, part of Imperial university London. he's a man that’s spent his whole life discovering the way to make products which might be as comfortable and secure to apply as feasible, whether or not it’s someone using mining or navy gadget, or an elderly person the usage of a automobile once they’ve surpassed their physical height. 

We offered Mansfield with a diffusion of controllers, from the NES’ iconic gray rectangle, through to the Nintendo 64, the Sony DualShock and the present day Xbox One pad, and he commented on the entirety from hand positioning, button design, and finger placement. 

Mansfield isn't a gamer himself, so he was not able to comment on how a proficient user would possibly approach the controllers, but the factor of the design that he specialises in is that some thing your stage of familiarity with gaming, you ought to have the identical knowledge of the way a controller works. 

The maximum thrilling observation of the consultation was perhaps Mansfield’s declaration that ‘curvy isn't always the same as ergonomic’. although curves give you a higher indication of where your palms ought to take a seat, they restrict the range of hand sizes which can use a controller. Curves may make a controller more cozy for an adult’s arms, but it'll have a poor impact on how clean it's miles for a child to use. 

in the meantime, extra angular designs may not match absolutely everyone’s hands perfectly, however they received’t be completely uncomfortable for any one hand size. 

So without in addition ado, let’s jump right into raking the controllers, which we’ve achieved from worst to satisfactory. click through for the entire run down.

ranking: three/10

Mansfield had little love for Nintendo’s Wii successor, “there are so many reasons why that is worse than all of the others that we’ve visible.”

but as opposed to any particular problems with the shape and length of the controller, it became the GamePad’s middle second-screen concept that he took the largest difficulty with. 

“The idea which you have a screen that is 40cm from the face and a display this is far away means you’re already ruling gameplay out for people who don’t have glasses on who are forty five-50 years old,” he explains, “The fact that the screen is so near manner that someone who hasn’t got right short vision, someone who’s lengthy-sighted like the whole population who're over 50, will war to see this at the distance which it's miles designed to be used.”

“in that case are you looking ahead to a person to wear bifocals for you to use this?”

“i would assume humans the usage of them could really get very tired eyes from repeated modifications of in which their interest is.” 

although the buttons themselves were satisfactory and tactile, Mansfield commented that he thought it is probably clean for a user to lose track of which button their finger was on, “There’s not considered one of them with a dot on it, so there’s nothing on right here to suggest which one’s which...if you’ve were given the one with the nodule on, the smooth one, the hard one and the wavy one, then that gives you a further manner of remembering what they do.”

The controller’s one redeeming quality became that it has plenty of places on your palms to grip the controller with out by chance urgent any of its buttons, that means that your fingers aren’t in a careworn position while protecting the console. 

however even that could’t redeem the GamePad for this ergonomics professor, who ranked the GamePad as the worst of the controllers he tried with us. 

ranking: 5/10

If ever there was a controller that would confuse a contemporary target audience it’s the N64’s. Designed at a time whilst the industry hadn’t determined whether the D-pad or the Joystick must be the number one input, the controller compromised with a three-handled layout which quite actually put the selection in the consumer’s arms. 

once we clarified how the controller changed into imagined to be held with Mansfield, he started his discussion with the shoulder buttons. 

“i'm able to’t grip this with those [index] palms, because I’m scared that I’d do something accidental in the game. So at this factor here I’ve were given  fingers which are correctly in a pressured position...they haven’t given me a finger relaxation at the lower back right here.”

He did but like the texture of the controller’s face buttons. despite the fact that the throw (the distance they travel whilst you press them) become big, and for this reason horrific from an ergonomics angle, this had the advantage of proscribing the hazard of unintended key presses, “You’re continually compromising between unintentional inputs and those that you need to be very sensitive and quick.”

the biggest problem with the controller become its size. Its small, curvy handles provide the affect of a controller that’s designed for youngsters, however the variety of motion required by means of the user’s thumb to transport among the console’s ‘A’ and ‘B’ buttons may be very hard with a smaller hand. 

“It feels find it irresistible’s a child’s toy, that’s the important thing with this” he concludes.

rating: five/10

The GameCube controller’s length became the unmarried biggest difficulty Mansfield identified, which affected the controller’s ergonomics by way of cramping the distance between the C-stick and the face buttons and the D-pad and the analogue stick. 

particularly, the C-stick’s positioning at the extreme left of the right-hand thumb’s range of motion could make it tough to function over lengthy intervals of time. 

Mansfield turned into but more fantastic about the shape of the face buttons. “you may distinguish between which button is which very without difficulty without looking and that’s always a good aspect.”

“You’ve were given every other channel; you could look at it or you could sense it, there’s a redundancy in that gadget, you don’t want to preserve on looking at it to understand in which your thumb is.”

however that didn’t trade the reality that the ergonomics professor genuinely concept the GameCube controller changed into definitely too small for person hands. 

Sorry break gamers. 

rating: five/10

compared to the GameCube controller, the Xbox 360’s pad is a much better suit for person fingers. Mansfield liked the extra limited movement of the thumbsticks which places much less of a stress at the arms, and the positioning of the triggers supposed that he should without difficulty rest his fingers on the top of them with out worry of accidental presses. 

He turned into much less of keen on the asymmetrical positioning of the analogue sticks, which he stated creates an imbalance in how you operate the controller. 

“The distinction this is pretty obvious on right here whilst using those two joysticks you do ought to preserve them in pretty distinctive ways.” He explained that at the same time as the left is operated with the tip of the thumb, the hand’s herbal inclination is to operate the proper with the thumb’s joint and this “wishes a good deal extra motion because you’re efficiently the use of one fewer articulation within the hand with a view to make the motion.”

however the biggest hassle became reserved for the controller’s huge battery compartment on the lower back, which limits the amount of area for the center, ring and little palms to rest. 

“The hassle is not the first five minutes, but it’s once you’ve performed for an hour. you haven't any alternative, you can't placed your arms everywhere else, there’s nowhere else for them to move.” he concludes. 

ranking: 6/10

There’s loads to love approximately the Dualshock’s iconic design. It has an awful lot wider handles than its competitors, main to a more at ease protecting role, and the distinction in texture between the D-pad at the left and the face buttons on the proper is any other small contact to permit you to discriminate among them based totally on experience by myself. 

Mansfield’s predominant criticisms have been levelled on the controller’s analogue sticks and their “great” movement range, which would be even greater sevre in a child’s smaller fingers. even though better for smaller motions, he worried that the large tour would make huge moves fatiguing. 

He additionally levelled complaint at the face buttons, the iconic circle, rectangular, pass and triangle, for being too a long way apart. 

“If i was talking to Sony I’d ask them why they’ve put the buttons thus far aside on the proper, because I don’t apprehend why....it’s pretty tough to move from one to the alternative and they might be plenty nearer.”

“I’m trying to keep it as much as the light to see in which they’re wiped out, due to the fact I assume they’re all worn out at the inside side,” he joked. 

rating: 6/10

Of all of the controllers examined at the day, the NES’s changed into the simplest. With just  buttons and a D-pad, Mansfield said that the controller will be picked up and quick enjoyed with the aid of almost each person, whether they were 3 years old or 100 and three years antique. 

“I recognise what each such a buttons does via searching at it,” he explains. 

From the quick throw of the buttons, to the controller’s mild weight (word: we were the use of controllers produced for the NES conventional Mini in 2016 in preference to originals) Mansfield had loads of love for the retro pad.  

Mansfield’s largest complaint turned into levelled on the controller’s D-pad. Textbook product layout might say that the D-pad need to be oriented to in shape the direction of the palms. because the palms are maintaining the NES controller at an perspective, Mansfield reasoned that preferably the D-pad ought to be rotated to the proper with the aid of round forty five-tiers to healthy this. 

but inside the long run he conceded which you’d grow to be “mapping your finger moves into a special size to the manner the controller movements.”

ranking: 7/10

compared to the Xbox 360 pad that got here before it, Mansfield turned into plenty extra high-quality about the Xbox One controller. mainly, the disappearance of the battery p.c. at the again to “locate their very own comfortable position.” 

but it changed into the smaller trends that ended up making the larger impact to its normal usability, “It’s lighter, the joysticks themselves are barely smaller so I assume they could paintings better for all arms, and the grip is a surely nice tactile floor.”

universal Mansfield notion the Xbox One controller had a miles clearer identity than the 360 pad we showed him, however he wasn’t as a lot of keen on the triggers which didn’t present as clean a resting function for the index fingers. 

score: 7/10

After Mansfield criticised the DualShock three for its analogue sticks and face buttons, the DualShock 4 regarded to have taken those actual criticisms on board with its adjustments to the classic DualShock system. 

“The movement on each of these joysticks is smaller from one to the alternative, which I think is progress...the space between those buttons at the right is closer. So that is a massive development over the previous era,” he explains. 

The controller’s grips also are longer, meaning more hands can unfold the load extra lightly during the hand. 

persevering with, Mansfield says, “the attitude of the handles has been designed to be a lot extra neutral...it’s emphasising that impartial position, so I assume that works honestly pretty nicely.” 

though the DualShock four become one of the maximum complicated controllers examined, these design selections avoided it from becoming overwhelming. Mansfield rated the controller as a vast development over previous versions, noting, “The differences are pretty diffused but from an ergonomics perspective they’re pretty essential.”

ranking: 8/10

As the sort of radical departure from traditional recreation controllers, the Wii suffers from few of the ergonomic proceedings levelled at its predecessors. 

the biggest change is the way you preserve its  portions, the Wiimote and Nunchuck in separate palms. this indicates your arms may be best and wide aside as you operate the console, in a neutral ‘shoulder-width apart’ role. 

It’s additionally ambidextrous, that means that it really works with left-exceeded and right-surpassed humans equally as properly.

The WiiMote has a flat back, however Mansfield emphasises that this doesn’t make it un-ergonomic. “precise ergonomics doesn’t suggest it’s curvy,” he says, “suitable ergonomics means it suits all people, and now and again, for some thing like this, the fact that it hasn’t got contouring at the returned of the battery compartment manner that it fits anyone's palms tons greater effortlessly than if it became designed for a five year antique’s fingers.” 

even though its use of batteries way the WiiMote turned into a little heavier than the others on test, but Mansfield defined that this wouldn’t positioned as a great deal of an unnatural pressure to your body due to the relatively larger motions you’re making with the controller. 

“It’s easy, inclusive, lots of complexity hidden in it but you could engage with it from day one,” he concludes.

Share on Google Plus